Judge Orders Insurer to Pay on Small Business Ransomware Claim



Hand about to bang gavel on sounding block in the court room-1Despite attempting to deny the claim revolving around a 2016 ransomware attack, a recent court ruling has caused an Ohio insurer to help cover the losses.

We’ve heard this story a few times before in the news; company X has a ransomware attack, they put in a claim with insurer Y, and the insurer denies the claim. Seem all too familiar. In the case of National Ink & Stitch, a Maryland screen printing business, the 2016 attack left them unable to access needed operational data on their servers. Even after paying the ransom, an additional ransom was demanded, causing the victims to seek help from a security firm to help remediate the situation.

A claim was placed into State Auto Property & Casualty Insurance in the amount of $310K for “direct physical loss of or damage” to property including stored media files. But State Auto denied the claim, saying “files” aren’t a physical loss.

But the recent ruling by Judge Stephanie A. Gallagher, of the U.S. District Court of Maryland found that the policy language did not support State Auto’s position that National Ink & Stitch’s computer systems “require an utter inability to function.”

While good news for insureds, it’s important to understand what exactly is covered by your cyber insurance policy. In the State Auto case, this came down to an interpretation of words in the policy – this demonstrates how crucial it is to go over with your insurer what scenarios are covered rather than simply thinking because you have a policy, you’re covered.


Free Ransomware Simulator Tool

Bad guys are constantly coming out with new strains to evade detection. Is your network effective in blocking all of them when employees fall for social engineering attacks?

KnowBe4’s "RanSim" gives you a quick look at the effectiveness of your existing network protection. RanSim will simulate 18 ransomware infection scenarios and 1 cryptomining infection scenario and show you if a workstation is vulnerable.

RanSimScreen-1Here's how it works:

  • 100% harmless simulation of real ransomware and cryptomining infections
  • Does not use any of your own files
  • Tests 19 types of infection scenarios
  • Just download the install and run it 
  • Results in a few minutes!

Get RanSim!

PS: Don't like to click on redirected buttons? Cut & Paste this link in your browser:

https://www.knowbe4.com/ransomware-simulator

Topics: Ransomware

Subscribe To Our Blog


Your Coronavirus and Work From Home Resource Center




Get the latest about social engineering

Subscribe to CyberheistNews